Matte Lipstick vs. Creamy Lipstick: Finding Your Perfect Lip Look

Matte Lipstick vs. Creamy Lipstick: Finding Your Perfect Lip Look

Okay, picture this: I’m standing in the drugstore, staring at a wall of lipsticks, totally overwhelmed. Sound familiar? If you’re as obsessed with makeup as I am, you’ve probably been torn between grabbing a matte lipstick or a creamy lipstick. Both are total game-changers, but they’re like night and day. I’ve spent way too many hours testing lipstick variety to figure out what works, so let’s dish on the differences, my fave picks, and how to choose the right one for you. Whether you’re into bold matt lipstick shades or soft creamy lipstick shades, I’m spilling all my secrets!

Matte Lipstick: The Bold BFF

I swear, matte lipstick is like that friend who’s always extra—confident, dramatic, and here to stay. It’s got that velvety, no-shine finish that makes your lips pop. Think of a classic red or a deep plum matt lipstick shade that screams “I’m here!” I wore best matte liquid lipstick (Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink, anyone?) to a friend’s wedding last month, and it didn’t budge through speeches, cake, or dancing.

Why I’m Obsessed

  • Stays Forever: Matte lipstick is your ride-or-die for long days. I’ve had good matte lipstick brands like Fenty Beauty last through coffee, lunch, and happy hour.

  • Major Impact: The flat finish gives your lips that sharp, defined look. I love rocking a nude matt lipstick shade for work or going bold with a berry tone for date night.

  • Budget-Friendly Finds: You can score a matte lipstick under 100 (like Essence or Wet n Wild in some stores) and still look like a million bucks.

The Downside

Matte can be a bit high-maintenance. It sometimes dries out my lips, especially in winter. I’ve learned to scrub my lips with a sugar scrub and slap on some balm before applying. Also, pairing a matte lip with a sleek Eye Liner (like a cat-eye) takes the whole look to boss level.

Creamy Lipstick: The Comfy Classic

Now, creamy lipstick is like slipping into your favorite hoodie—cozy, easy, and always feels good. Creme lipstick or cream colour lipstick has this soft, hydrating vibe that’s perfect when I just want to look polished without trying too hard. My go-to? Creamy lipstick Maybelline Color Sensational in a peachy nude. It’s like my lips, but better.

Why I’m Obsessed

  • Feels Amazing: Best creamy lipstick formulas, like ones with shea butter, keep my lips happy and hydrated. MARS creamy matte lipstick is another fave—it’s kinda matte but not drying at all.

  • No Fuss: I can swipe on creamy lipstick shades like pink or coral in my car (don’t judge) and still look put-together.

  • Natural Glow: The slight sheen of creme lipstick makes my lips look juicy without being glossy. Perfect for Zoom calls or coffee dates.

The Downside

Creamy lipsticks don’t always last as long, so I’m reapplying after lunch or a latte. They can also smudge if I’m not careful, so I use a lip liner. Oh, and creamy lipstick pairs so well with a fun Eyeshadow Palette—think soft shimmers to match the vibe.

Creamy Matte Lipstick: The Best of Both?

Okay, if you’re like me and can’t pick a side, creamy matte lipstick is your new bestie. It’s got the bold color of matte but feels like a creamy lipstick. I’m obsessed with creamy lipstick Maybelline Creamy Matte in Touch of Spice—it’s this perfect rosy-brown that works for everything. It’s not as drying as a true matte, so my lips don’t hate me by the end of the day.

How I Pick My Lipstick

Choosing between matte lipstick and creamy lipstick is all about the mood I’m in. Here’s how I decide:

  • Big Plans? I grab a best matte liquid lipstick for staying power. Think weddings, parties, or when I’m filming Instagram reels.

  • Chill Days? Creamy lipstick is my go-to for running errands or casual hangs. Creamy lipstick Maybelline nudes are my everyday MVPs.

  • Want Both? Creamy matte lipstick for bold color with comfort. It’s like the perfect middle ground.

  • Skin Tone Tip: I’ve got warm undertones, so I lean toward corals or warm reds. Cool undertones? Try mauves or cool pinks. Test shades at the store or use a virtual try-on app.

  • Complete the Look: A sharp waterproof eyeliner keeps my makeup game strong, especially with a bold lip.

My Fave Lipsticks

  • Matte: NYX Soft Matte Lip Cream in Copenhagen—affordable and gorg!

  • Creamy: Creamy lipstick Maybelline Color Sensational in Pink Petal. So soft!

  • Creamy Matte: MARS creamy matte lipstick in a deep berry. Obsessed.

FAQs: Your Lipstick Questions, Answered

Q: Which lipstick is better for chapped lips?
A: Creamy lipstick all the way—it’s super hydrating. If you want a matte look, try creamy matte lipstick or slather on lip balm before matte lipstick.

Q: How do I keep matte lipstick from flaking?
A: Exfoliate with a lip scrub (I use a DIY sugar-honey mix) and apply a thin layer of balm. Blot after the first layer of matte lipstick, then add another swipe.

Q: Any good matte lipsticks under 100?
A: Yep! Check out Essence or Colorbar for matte lipstick under 100 (depending on where you shop). They’re pigmented and won’t break the bank.

Q: Can creamy lipstick work for fancy events?
A: Totally! A bold creamy lipstick shade like a deep red looks glam with a lip liner to keep it crisp. Add [waterproof eyeliner] for extra drama.

Q: What’s the deal with creamy matte lipstick?
A: It’s a hybrid—bold like matte lipstick but smoother and less drying, like creamy lipstick. Perfect if you want color without the parched feeling.

Q: How do I pick a shade for my skin?
A: Warm undertones rock corals or warm reds; cool undertones shine with pinks or mauves. Not sure? Nudes like creamy lipstick Maybelline Toasted Truffle work for most!

Wrapping It Up

Whether I’m feeling the fierce vibes of matte lipstick or the cozy glow of creamy lipstick, there’s a perfect lip color for every day. Play around with matt lipstick shades or creamy lipstick shades to find what makes you feel like you. And don’t sleep on creamy matte lipstick for that best-of-both-worlds magic. Pair your lip look with a killer Eyeshadow Palette or a slick Eye Liner, and you’re ready to take on the world. So, what’s your favorite lip color? Spill the tea in the comments—I’m dying to know!

Back to blog